Uttar Pradesh Real Estate Regulatory Authority
Sanjay Prakash Srivastava v. Project Category-Un-Register SWASTIK MULTITRADE PRIVATE LIMITED
Complaint No. LKO162/12/0518/2019
- Decision date
- 2020-10-19
- Text availability
- Full text
- Bench
- Adjudicating Officer Lucknow
Source: UP RERA order
Connected provisions and cases
No further provision or case links are recorded.
Judgment text
sogo frftqrqo srtrCF, gr, Er€mrF I T-SqEr qftq rrqq, qrsq ffiqq ripfrq, o,rf,rfrio{ 6t\NT *€ tqqqrq, Fr€lq$-226ooz fts-or ?FFr;rTftm (wewr)sqfuft:- ffi 1. Rro,rqd rfteql LKOr62t08n7t4t20t9 sr rtil-Kq 2. Rrorqf, ste{r LKOt62t08n709t20l9 qrqr tfr Rro.rqd rfql LKOI62t08t1718l20l9 ffiBlqr& Rrf,rqd riqr LKOL62t09l1300l20r9 gfrwH frlopn sqr : LKor62 togtttztizotg rro €w sftqrwq Rrolqf, vtsfi : LKor6zroltrz2szorg fl-{ril Eh{rwq 7. Rrolqd irqr : LKor62togtr72gzor9 Etq RiE Rroprf, Tfqr : LKor62to8/r778tzot9 q{NTNTT O-6AITuT ENT e. Rrotqd rfqr i LKor62t0gtr7lrt20r9 +6r +fr{rwq r o. Rrorqf, Tfwr : LKor62t0gtrzgst20l9 3Trat{ {f,{ r r. Rrorqe Tfqr : LKol62t09ll29ll20r9 fuol irlstT rz. Rrorqf, irqr : LKor62 rlgn2gztzlrg qrnfr RiE
z LKor62r0lrr720r20rg rs. RroT{f, sql gfrwH 1a. ft6r+a rfql i LKor62r0gtrsst,a0tg rifrq qq atqrwq rs.Rrorqtr Tfqr LKOt62mt0t3912019 ereol qqf ro.Rrorqa sqr LKOr62lr1/0188/2019 q-{TrE {r$q rz.Rrorqo riqr LKOI62nlt0t99l20l9 dro-r tfr re. Rrorqf, TfqI LKOr62t09/1346t20r9 cffi6 LKOt62t09t1298l20l9 rg. Rrorqf, sql rqr rro fYe zo. Rrorqtr Tiqr LKOt62n2t0518l20l9 €urq ro-RI Efil-wq zr. Rrorqf, TiqI : LKor62 tr2t0sz3t20r9 dvq qqn afl-qrwq qrft.rul erofuo,EIRilo Tdis t rm TrR / st frn6 srrg qfuqrfrat-ct"k5'l
sTrtqr frqeft d frs-€ afrqrwq d qrpr loctq ffi FRI ffi wr q-ft gq qrfr rrril=T d t wft neq \'q srs \rtnfri-o.f{d dftil-d 01 ffi d t r 2 (4qqg1 gq-st T{EqRrd Rrorqd 'Rrriqr qrd +riR-l' t t t ero, gfi fr trq t qcnnT sfl-q|-wq ftffR"r fuqr qI t r R[+-rqf, ficql LKor62tov/r7r4/20r9 {qr I Gr.Jrft Rrfl-{a rtn qRR*, rqd Rrol-{o eTp|ilq' { ffirrq ARI frqeft d frs-€ r q|fu-d o1 .nft ffif, qrq qFo oGcTr ffi qd tg t
ftqeft qdq d ffi""r i cTq-ft Rrorcrd q oifuT fuqr t fu B-si rErT err refre go s-qlql ftN$ o1 qMriqT 'ffiqq qrd +f,eq-l' 6sqgr t \'o qur qeif vrq+r fr ffi-rq gmr q-flRT q'1 Grflq{ft at qfr t E}+i d q frqeft q-y @cTT 36 rT16 ci-gqiq-qt d s-r+{-11(F) d ergwn Eo-rgffia q qr t fu-g frqeft 3ngq+T-qf,FKr tfl. rflfud forfR-f, 3mfu d ffi-pr oi o-"qr ti d erqrqef {fl, fuqr o-rwr ffiq"r Hrqt T-vrRfEr ftfuqmo q--{rfr Tft | nfu-{-{q qftfuqq of qrsr-sr d er-<rda frqefr d frs-€ Rro-rqa (d srcr: gr-{r {o'[$ 61 asuTr ftmd q[i ot{ M-r"r qR frqeft o-"nr fti
r u.RRr qFNrqfi fr ersqef t d ffi qfi tg qfqil of ufr t +t eEe-€T-q-r, trq-grfu GTqrqrfr ot frrop-ao-oi-rq grqr GTTi qrE d vrqeh vqfi-i {{trd cilq eil-qrq-o q{flffq) of urqrqffi Erfud of .rfr d t qwr.rf, qffiq-fl frqqfr FKr GTq-i ftfud erfuoerq q cifu-d fu-qr -rql t fu .rqr en riqrrrfl d sqer orrffi fu-qroT ildrr-d qrqfu{ TS-qn F-qri tg fu-dT qD} rrqr qtanq R-{i-ff 16.12.2o1s fudr rfqr+d gxr qmfur r+ed fr;+rffi
erT qero qfi q{-zors d qffiqfl- t ov+u fuf,K{ qr|ffi-{"r d ffion d 1fr 3i-f,dn sqfuf, of Tft ,fr fus ol{ur frqeft o} qr{.rd qffiq-{r o-r fuom ord qrqil eft, qfu qrw srfr q-Srto oq +{lgr adq.-d qrqfot o1 rffi Td d emeq-{-drcTf errrt-q E} Tfr eft r w-d qrqrT tnrdq ofildq-_c flqfua a1 {ffir 26.os.2o1s o} wlkfr ercqRrq d fuor-s d ftg ft-{i-ffof 9pf qr{d tg \.-- qeq yo o-q16* sr$tf,l q-c*is eTofuo Tq frq qrd gqrffire eTofto d .fr-q eo gcnr Qn | frqfr ersl ftqio 2l.os.2o1s o) ffi, +f,flf,rd .rq fr ffifl q{ qd-€f, dNqRTq frfr d e-ao rn dNqRTq d fuqrrs tg v6\Es Tfr
q-qr qT grgr qeqq dcFrs' f,trf,rfl xrfoo-sq dr{trfl d fuq oil-fqq fuil ffi err t dcrl\F fd+-rs qltrff-{"r dfu{io 16.0e.2015 o) dr{s-fl d-qd ft,+r rrqr gxt R-{r6 21.03.2016 oi qMwfl ol fr-t1dcrg*-fi d ci-jqrim q frqeft qMGrqr r|{rr eil d€r"KF' fum-R{ wrff,-{q g|-{I fu{rf ffid Erfu-d fuqr | 26.0s.2017 o) qffiqql oT adq.-e qmh? fu{i-fi 2s.os.zo22 a-o d ft\ TfrEf, q-$-6-{,'r R-;rrf qfuilwfl o-r Boeo i-{r d rrqeffuqr rrcn- il | frqqt gnr qt{il-{rcil0e.03.2018 oi o-{r fuqr rrqr er vq t-{ d +fd w qMq{r d frftiq
e} | frqft cft sqdeT tnirt Ti oilr {ftfoqr d Irfl"r qad v+req w qrqor-{ dsrt qE ffittq o}em tnq ftrqr .rqr t qffiq{r ol f,e-slq @Td X"f or-qBE6Tr trEr=T o-{i d fuq ilqR d r q|Fo-sq d sniq d orqq ss wrFI at znrd etT qE frqqfr d Frq-dq d T€t eT ftorfl trr fuqr.rqrffi fdq qffiq-{r ci-Tq-.el qa d rra<-ro@ d sifttdeil t lffiq-q yq frqeft d qeq ffii on"r qR fuqeft w:oxlfrftqq{ qrtrfi{'r ot ofu, t{Mu-drt fu qT Tfi d qror frqeft sfuofuiifuo srrq Gr-{fu q oilTA o} F-6qr rcrq qfr o-< t d
o-{ lrcndT d' 3nqftdi o} et$ oT|fo-R TS a}fl fu wqrqrcrr q qrfir ffi rTr-tr er+qlRr sTqrf of of t frqeft FKr oTqi qfl nQqq6 cEq€T qa o) TfiTTkr o-s
rTToqr qrT qrrfi-q ritrf,r eTfufrqq, oTkf,-{"r 1'q ti Sq {6nfq T-vrqqr cTffiq q-KR-32 fi erfuiil oeq qtl qR crge=tT .n d1e0B .nI rl<rf td gS filt-ffifl f,+rfR-dfrqeft sron/ftftqq-q qrtrfi{"r o1 ofu, ftMTf,r qI q-r d on"r gq+ qRRQTfr oi sN 6-swr rfl;T -r€f os qror t dsqq erqfu ti ffi 6) ci-'il.ff, qrqr ql$rn If-qf{ of ffi d qa fr{Rrn frr} qd ot ergtu fuql Grcr: frqeft snr ffieif ol cn-g-fir qe d fufl-{sx fufl-fl gGF'fleTT .rqr fu ffi-qq ui 66pl+d-or qR qTq cTr+rr ot-{fr ftorfl qri d *{ fr} T@ ci-Er o-s rFGTT fuS eTTft qqr r+sRr qTwT qrafr d n} cTFJq er-flRr ot odft orffi-pr
t*q erflfu rrrqT or srot t fqqfr gm erqi wqeh d ftq6op. HIerI Erbd frd rri d :- e-rTIuT q-{ | 16.12.201s e} fudr qqrtrf, exr qrfr qMwqr or tftqo 1. ft{'- 2. fuoiru 2s.01.2o1a o) dEFrrF' fuf,rfl eTDo.gq FI-{ \il-ft qR*qq oI d-qd rrTrul q-{ | qerfirtt der rflrq-fr q{ sqrrel vrrftl 3Tkfrdi oI d il+T o) 5-il ci-q-drf,-{ fuqr qqr I q6 qr-q ffifu( REet} w ryfn' cTffi d cr{dn-{ t se t fu eireTlRf, t,- ererqr or{ut gs fi-s or effifil-{ t 1. qqr si-garrq d 3il'ffiFn .rffi *i d T€f ? gnr frqefr oi ergv+r qa d q-gsn cTfrfuffi Teo. ftql 2. trqr ffirrq erel-qr rS ? qrqr sfoo t eierqr rfr ? 3. Eqr fqqfr of qMwil ffif, B ftKKq ft€ dqr-l eifud qd e-o l4qeft d am emi eng{.tT-.n d rwq-+s d s-f,Td {6 fuqr rr:qr :- t 43- All or any disputes arising out of or touching upon or in relation to the terms of this Agreement including the interpretation and validity of the terms thereof and the
s h,/ respective rights and obligations of the parties shall be settled amicably by mutual discussion failing which the same shall be settled through Arbitration. The arbitration proceedings shall be governed by the Arbitration and conciliation Act, 1996 and/or any statutory amendments/ The modifications thereof for the time being in force. arbitration proceedings shall be held at an appropriate location in Luclonw, U.P. by a shole Arbitrator who shall be appointed by the Company. The Intending Allottee(s) hereby comforms that the Intending Allottee(s) shall have no objection to such appointment by the Company or have any doubts about the impartialtty of the sole Arbitrator, appointed by the Company. The Courts at Luclonw alone and the Uttar Pradesh High Court alone shall have the jurisdiction in all matters arising out ofl touching and/ or concerning this Agreement regardless of the place of execution of this Agreement which is deemed to be at Luclopw .
sEre-ffi qt{f qeif d qtg qR frtS fi v-on or t qe rfi-d Etdr t fu q-wry q-6qfr Arbitration ect d ei-f,Td ffifl t Wfu{rE drdr t d} sso} tftrqr utt'rn fu61 1'5 qn fdrfu6g Fl-cF1F' fr *'n zr-6 trKn q-dqn qRie{ tt aq rfr *f,I, E-s wr*u d :- l- In Booz Allen and Hamilton Inc V/s SBI Home Finance Limited & Ors, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that all aspects of arbritrabilQ have to be decided by the court seized of the suit, and cannot be left to the decision of the Arbitrator. Even if an arbitration agreement exists and the dispute is covered therein, the court will refuse to refer the the subject matter of the suit is parties to arbitration - if the capable of adjucdication only by a public forum or relief clamied can only be granted by a spectal court or Tribunal.
2- A Ayyaswamy v A Paramasivam (CIWL APPEAL NO,S. 8245-8246 OF 2016) the Supreme Court held that there are classes of disputes thatfall within the exclusive domain of special bodies created under legislation that confers jurisdiction to the exclusion of ordinary civil courts. Such disputes would not then be capable of resolution by arbitration. 3- Ganesh Lonkar u/s D,S Kulkarni Developers Ltd, Maharashtra Real Estate Authority (MahakEM) has has taken the view that, despite the existence of an arbitration agreement between the parties, it has the jurisdiction to adjudicate disputes that are the subject of the arbitration agreement. The reasoning in the decision has two foundation. Firstly, the legislature is presumed to be aware of all lans enacted by it; as REM was enacted after the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (ACA), REM woild prevail over ACA. Secondly, the legislature contained in any other law for the time being in force. Thus, the provisions of REM override section 8 of ACA, which mandates a judicial authority to refer to arbitration disputes that are subject to an arbitration agreement. 4- In Aftab Singh and others vs Emaar MGF Land Limited and Another has held that The NCDRC further observed the importance of remedies available under the CPA and the special object and purpose of a beneficial legislation such as the CPA in protecting interests of consumers. The NCDRC reasoned that allowing Section 8 to oust the the jurisdiction of consumer fo, a would set at naught entire purpose and object of the consumer Act, which was to ensure speedy, just and expeditious resolution and disposal of consumer disputes. Exposure of such disputes to the Arbitration Act could invite application of portions of the A&C act that are enforceable only through Civil Courts. This would be repugnant to the manifest purpose underlying the enactment of the CPA, The NCDRC also briefly relied on Section 2(3) of the A&C Act which recognizes schemes under other legislations that make disputes non-arbitrable.
overall The NCDRC finatty held that in light of the architecture of the CPA and Court-evolved jurisprudence, amended sub-section (1) of Section 8 cannot be construed as a mandate to the Consumer Forum, constituted under the CPA, to refer the parties to arbitration in terms of the Arb itr at ion Agr e e me nt.
q-q srtffi ftqq qffitr foq tr sftff qro sqT@ ;sr-fl?F[ lo w.fi.S.ernfr FRr qrRd cil-M d cil-f6 tr6 q-frn srfus-{tril inr qbrfufi-R qrt fuo-f,f,rt srq t M t fu frtq Arbitration clause d errfigr tf +qrga qfr fuqr qr rrfiTr t I I( qTo qrcrc,rq gRr sfdr wfu trq fr qs ftJ-qrf, qffi{d fuq t fu q$ otr{ Arbitrator d qm qu .ft ftFfdfuo-E d fu frffi qrE d frFfd frt$ qrd t EtsT qrflIo-s+ d fdq r€t qmorii o\ fu{rq ffia o-{i d fuq t d qrqTFRI gt-{t q6 GTfrR-m qro sqta Arbitration o\ rM d fuq qfl otfl | {fld fiq-n-q,ft frFfd fu-qr rrqr fuqrq-{ sxr frR}q vrn fu{rE ffi fuq t fu N gq+ q_fi_R d +n_ft q*ilrru d GTfrfttr ffioiq fr+r. {qT te_{_$ T} t frq a.uitrator H€{TI qfr d tfd-{r-E oi ffif, ori d fug
q-E sil-ai-o d sq-$tr firdi d wE +nr t fu Rqd dc (5wo zoro of qr{I-29 Arbitration Act Tt 6ffrfrftqll-fr \q f,ffitw qTD-fi-ruD eTEft{q, st=fd qqfudr'n vq vqrfr1 arrtgr ori d frg fr fuqr ql ltcndl t, u\ t tr-g oTko-R eb q errol tlN.c.D.R.c.ie.eyyaswamyfr ild eiqlqiT) q ercrodf d gfi fr fuqrd Rrrf, €z qftftqq ddr=t o-{i d ftq qE M fuorin t fu q-fi-f,r gq fui d fl-q fuqrd dTfiT Btm ilrdr t oq El t d fu qmi t q-EH o-senv+rTrErrq d fuq \-6 f,dtE n-a t gV frqeft trNI Arbitrator Q) sqftD qftlvrkd RIqrdT of EMTo wfr
t qrot trffid osi or s{q RrI: fr rrqrw d ftKRq RE d'€qT-2 gKI G4-gqiq ergril-{ oTRfrffi g@ fuqr d qet tro qr{ ffirrq qeiiqrqr g-fuo Gr-g{+T qa d d qtq M{d erem q€[, gs r{Rt-q q fff t gs 10 Fq fu€ eifoa d :- Sale Price (Total of BSP+PLC) :
In addition to the Sale Price (BSP and PLC), the Intending Allottee(s) will be liable and agrees to pay: F'-' a) Stamp duty, legal and registration charges etc. Shall be extra at actual. b) External Development Charges and Infrastructure Development Charges as and when demanded by Company, more elaborately described in Clause 6 of this Agreement. c) Infrastrucfure Augm entation charges and any other Government levies/charges as and when demanded by Company, more elaborately described in Clause 6 of this Agreement. d) One time entrance fees for the Community Centre/Club as more elaborately described in clause 3(d) of this Agreement. e) Holding charges as more elaborately described in Clause 11(c) of this Agreement. construction penalty as more elaborately in Clause 0 Late l2(b) of this Agreement. g) Municipal tax, property taxo wealth tax, Service tax, fees, levies and charges by whatever name called and increases thereof if considered separately from the Government Charges as described above.
eifu-o :-{s-d oftfrffi TKr-(-6 q frq t Govt. Charges and Taxes While calculating the Sale Price of the plot, the Company has not taken into account the External Development Charges (for short referred as the "EDC") and Infrastructure Development Charges (referred to as the "IDC"), and other charges including but not limited to Infrastructure Augmentation Charges (referred to as "IAC") as levied by 10 Government of Uttar Pradesh and the Intending Allottee(s) accordingly agree(s) to pay to the Company Govt. charges (EDC,IDC IAC etc. are collectively herein referred to as Govt. Charges and all increases thereof as may be levied by the Government of Uttar Pradesh from time to time and as and when demanded by the Company. q=ilrl Ttrft ril{d tl qo q-d-@ amilErq ervi trq gw}6 {s q*rrer fugGTf q-t 2s.10.2018 d e-o.{q fr w.fr.S.enq.S. d ds of ftqHfuf, oTqi€ (sS arsrqD foqr B:-
"The Commission held that out of the charges mentioned in the Pre Possession Letter dated 12.10.2015, the Appellant- Builder was entitled to payment of the following {rmounts- (i) An amount of Rs. 3,1661- towards interest on delayed payment. (ii) Water connection charges if paid to the concerned Authority, on proportionate basis subject to furnishing proof of such payment, in terms of this order. (iii) Labour welfare charges subject to fumishing proof and computation with respect to the said charges in terms of this order.
R.s. (iv) Escalation charges + service tax amounting to 3,88,797.r9/ o1 tN trq{rfu t fr-}iq, d{r ffiD TKf{ d fu€r EnT Erqd t Fo.t-S fuqrq[dq, q[d qf$rg, qffieqn oTw, eTrR qn fuqis qft sft, ffi fuffrd qn|q of GTqi df€ d sqjq d frn B sfldrrqr fu fu€{ sKr d ?rdq LI rr{t-6-I ggqlft-f 3RTrJrroR .nI IrrTTur (eroof of payment) toq q ,rct-o erw d ero' ffiwt (proportionate Share) Tflfi gq 16 flfl-Rr ti d eTffi eti t I qri or Erfu€ tq) fturr5vx orT{+T d eqvm cTfrR-ffi g@ f,{n ftKrqur frE riwr-3
d orQTqr T€1, qS c-o rR;T frqeft et qfuff,{r ffif, t {s qqiq 3G q[6 fr o-qt ?D-r 6Qr"T e fu frqeft FKr 3i-gwtT tra of ftfU tffi.rur oT tnsFT t fuIrEFT fuql qrqr en, errfr ao rEFT o61 four .rqr t | frqfr N dq{-zors q qMqqr rQtrT a1 TF FIEFI\F fu6m qrkog"r d ffion ?Fr{q frqefr o} qT{q-f, qffiqqr or fuors ord eft fuflci-f,.fd sqfuT o1 q-fr efr, qfu Td d qrqrto or +{Rr ildr.cc qnfua o1 ffi qFil or-ft q.S efi GI+IraI df .rftacq.e-c qnErt of ffi t d€t"t\b. fuo-rfl qlfuo-gq gRI 2s.0s.2022 ao d fuqfrqi-fi 26.0s.2012 o) qMwqr oT acq.e qmfod fu{i-fi 3ifu-d qe{firvt rrqr ci-g-fiT qa d e-Kf{-32 G) tdqd fOqr d qq ffid t r tfu'- Any legislation, order or rule or regulation made or issued by the Govt. or any other authority or if any Governmental Authority (ies) refuseso delayes, withholds, denies the grant of necessary approval for the Said Township or if any matters, issues relating to such approvals, permissions, notices, notifications by the Governmental Authority (ies) become subject matter of any suiVwrit before a competent Court or; for any reason whatsoever;
12 qrko--{uT q-f,H err w6e fu qR fuorfl { sffi t t fu lM'rq d qMrqfl .ilFm t qqRrf, oiltrr{o qnfrz Bqrrer F-{r} qd { ft-dq fdr t frqqft of eTfuoR Etq-r fu q-6 o6Tr rEFr o-si of frfu o) {ieiltrf, or soar t q?FT{ qrq eTemr yfufr( qrw ovi d 3Tffi T€fvq orrf0 frrff or ffio qMqqr zg.os.2o22 offud atdfi r fqqeft gnr tg|. d ffd w d Wt* ftf* q-Sq-ft t t qffiqqr d d{ funq e | {n FFr{ frqet qfr crd *.q qrpllr-qt qifum sv t ffifirt frtn il{jsr-{ ffiwr or tr q6 eTrtql qfr ftfU d oo fu{ d ci-q{ ftqfr of eil-eftrn frrfl qr-f,r t fu rrTqT o-{ ondf,ff EfrTg o1 {frf$ srrqxffiwr t tq frfu6 ilflfu
t trEFT osr gfrfrao ofrqr (frft{qq oel fuors) sTDft{q, zoto ot gw entw o-[ sdwt T-irRfET qtrsftq qtfd q-{ *Tr r orffuer-{-63 cTQrr Gr,tr gq-.ro qrhqrqT d cffl.ff, I€nq-drs fuil qrd sTrtq. ffi d Rrorqfl or ftwrsq furrl qnr tt t qft sfr d'rffi qrd gq sqRrf, q*rqfudi q cil-eqldrfd w eiqfrs fuil qrd ffim- o /ro/zozo k-Jthfoblrr!. (oewr frqr) WtrFII grtrfi{"r sogo T-StrrET frfuqrro 13