Uttar Pradesh Real Estate Regulatory Authority
Raghunandan Singh Rathore v. U.P. Awas Evam Vikas Parishad
Complaint No. LKO162/08/80457/2021
- Decision date
- Not recorded
- Text availability
- Full text
- Bench
- Adjudicating Officer Lucknow
Source: UP RERA order
Connected provisions and cases
No further provision or case links are recorded.
Judgment text
yilticp^ui, r fg WT, W&1 Plgldd ggRTggcfR n^ ^R-egg, ei'i'tl g^ 3Ttdg d'JsHvJo—226007 *fto-01(g) jfcT :- 3ft gTvjftg g|gR (3TE2TST) vJgf^ Ws?TT:-LKO162/08/80457 /2021Rlchl^d ftn? Kiolx .ftlggg?Tg>df g.g. 3TTgRT gg Rq>m HR ®K, 104 gfsft gpf, *15lrMI ci'igiv* I .fclgaft
cjTT cpojii, T g> fcR RlelR^d STgf^ egM gg cflg- ^rf Rl0Nd0dI gRT <^plc ^fclRqrl ^d^lRl g^tRdR dP cRTT fcfgsft gKI’jRf g> WT HlJfl gl? pRgT |<1R|£| Rlc^Nd qiRsid cf?t g*ft 1? vgRt^ gsfg 3 Rl<DNd0dI gRT 3Tg^t Rl^Nd gg 3iRhd Rbgl ^T^TT 1? 1% v3d<1> gKI |c|d Tsl d'iSMvb g> 3T?FfcT gg> Jll^ ^d'elcl, il'l'jHl ggg^cft ^ 'tWcM—20, ^ gg fcfgaft gRT Ricpiddcpdi g> g5T Pdiq>—27.01.2016 grtgcfe WTT-20/D-2-802 M^ddd gg 3llqcd fct>gT gg[ 2g, fvjRfgg *iiPld 3i^ go 30,00,000/ — 2g, g0 16,10,500/- gft STgRPft g$t g?ft| Ricpitiacpdl
g> idN ff fctRgRT gg SjcHld gRTgT ggT t % g>tfcfg if|Rq>s ft KH4? gRT Rh^cft ^ f%gTgff R)d*g g> feR fcRsft gRT 13.5% egTvg gR t gO 1,25,665/ — gg '(idld'ldd ^ ggT gRT g? 3TgrRT gRTgT ggT t fcf> gvjftgRR Rdg>l ~$> 5RcR—9.1 11 R|g>Md<*>di ^ g^t srgf^rg> 3Tg/gR gc^g gg gffcfg? gjs3TT Pldlul gig-—gg Rgfgg g5t m ^ 30 w gfPTT gT WRT cTg> UgFT f%gTft ^jpf fcfgTT M*dlRld t 3Tgfg RdlV-27.07.2018 gR^ ggT gRT gf? STggg gg 4>®dl 3Pft cTg> ggTg f%gT 11 TgggcTgglf§cp|^ g^t f^ ^gRTgT ggT H-gg ff \RTgft 3TTgfecT t f% fcRaft gRT f^ gfgT 03.08.2021 g>T TtfacT M^ 3/ 1
ETT FFT CT2JT$0l4 ^ k|Ri|| if FFft FR 74.8 F7? "ft. if 72.02 cpf ft. FR f^ gtR k*Ri|| ^ cff^^Rf^ cf?t J FR 101.65 F^f ft. ft 101.87 F7! ft. FR ftFT Tpqj^fftraft ITRT TJRT 7JcF ft WT if SFRTfft F0 5,40,570/ — eft ^ fclRcjxl FTF eft VJTT 11 3TcT: fftjfRcT 3TFfft if 0<&jji F FFTF fftft Fnft ft Ri0iqd0df ETRT ^jRrs F^TRT j*RT ’jRfFF cpsjii, RdRqd 3TFfft ft feP? eZJM FF FTF Rdl^ FTlft cRTT fcTq^aft fftqT FFTijeq ft wr if ftft FI? sifciRcra SHFRI eft Ri^ -a 0^ 1^ unft srgfter tl :— ^TaF ^iRcfd fftif f | 1. FF R-110-27.01.2016 eft ftcT 3liqc-l/FTF | 2. !>ftF-1-FF R-1I0 03.08.2021 eft Fief | 3. Hd)0yu| ^R^i0| eft yfcf 4. ^9T?T—Ft?f eft flfcT|
| cl yvftejcQ FR fcfFaft eft 3l|c|q-| eft M^ ftR* ftft? FR Rl0Nd0Cli eftRwiqa ft FR if FFFF wn wi fctqraft gfm 3TFft fftfftF> yRPiRr ft FTWT ft C fdRsid vjicliq R-llft—01.10.2021 eft cl FR R|0|i|c10di eftV3HR«T? SW' M^fftFFFcT FF fcf)i|| qi|| | fcFrafr eJKI qiRsid MRC|K-FF if Tfi? eTcTRTT FFT 1? 1% <49^*1 Rl0|t|d0dl eft qRqq gKi <-idlfdd Fftft? kj-Fcft, '(We'<—20, ^-FN-I ftd-11 cT fftFT FFT FT | R|0Md0di eftFF?ftft ft? d<sMvfc eft i|Rft \ji-1l if STTcff^ Tfp| ?5f efrft-II0-27.01.2016 eft :<idiftl-1 ft fcfcRU[ <iRd 3iiq<i-i FF uffft ft)*?') TTCdR-1 if vJcftRfld t fft ?F?f FF T£CFfft?T FFT err I ftftfFRF ^Rd0| ft 30 FTF if fftFT FTFTT M'Mlftd 113FJFTfftcT t TTcf RRWT F?ft
FF fftrafr FFft MRCIK F? if Fvftc^ui qRd0i ft fftfft? 3R?ft fftFT FFT t fcfFaft RT F? iff vieft<sf fcfrFT W t f%> SffrR jcFl FTFTcT ’0-1 ^ FRFT f Fd^lRl F^t Far if FF RptcT fcfjFT FFT W^Rl0ldd0dl ^ F^ FeTcT 3TRFT ?f fuRTIdRcftii Rq^i FFRTF^T -^ R|0Nd0dl Far if FT^fRTcT F^ 2 y fcHl’ cf) 03.08.2021 cf>t f<tRT ^RTI Rlqdddq^df ETRT if <4*M—tpjf FTT^t sR*M—cp5f 3lRbd 3TcT?t^r fcHMlRl Jle1H RRT 7RT sfR *T i?t R^f—RcftsT cR *T eft ^3l)qdlRq>dl3ft cfTt xjof cfvf cpsjii MT RRT fvrRTc^ fcP? f^|c|?|«4c10clf ^cfzf vjfRT cf>T #Sf qpf cpy tld'dRl *R RCTR 3TFRRrRFR 11 3RT: Rl <^Nd0di 3rqFft | d^t %
— R^fift SKI 3TR TFfsR RMRIRICI SlR^d RR Rt If 1. MVJ?I KUI RdRI cR irfcf I <* ^ 2. 3|(qcd/WT W3 RdIR—27.01.2016 cj?f nfcT I 3. <sndiq£l cjff nfcT I 4. 16.06.2021 ?RT I iRsid-q^ RRRf> 03.08.2021^ ^fcT 29.12.2020 cf?f nfeT I 5. qRqlvJldl cf?[ ljufdl WHIUI—^T5T RdlR RR xTSTt R efR Rt RjR R vmidl 3RFRT if RF=T RdlRd RR VJTTCT f- zjR T 3RRr R fcP? ? 1. W fcpraff cj?r qRqlvjidi RlclRqd R iR f R R^ ^ TR t smciT ? 2. w fcpraft HM RR ^nft srfcrR^r EFRTRT RTW^ cpcFTT 3. W Ricplddqjdl Rt ? MR iR RldRqd 3fc[R cpT SfR Rdldl vJfT^ m eft RfRT R ? Pt*dKul RR ^KSqi —1
-qq *TF Pi^ % w R^rsft qRql'Jidi RciRqei sft ^fT RR 3 RTJTT w^n FT eft R^T 3TFR R fcR ?*R cpT WT Fcp qRRvrldl 3 fcfefR MR-9.1 3 t, quffcf^uT Rdq>l R ^ cfjf fcrf$T3lfcbd MlRNldRldf R >(lK d W tftfclW Cf?<SKJll ftMwf *TFN?T "^ f^Fjfw 3j^ UTFfT Uixilfila £" ?RTT fcpTfift ETRT R>? Rt 3pR# 30 W $ %uf fcfrzn cF? zn? 3FFRT cfRRT TRI f R>RlRsId STRcpapT RdlR 01.10.2021 *f vicvl^g
3 <2T cpojll IHull eft>;u| Rdcftl if ufPf cpf STcrf^r Pl^IRd ^n?t % f^if ^ cft]^ c|?| RfcjtiScf if cfj®if cj?f fclRf Slfcbcl S T?Pr e£ TFcRT if ^fTO Mvrilc^ \;u| ^ R^ sfRT M/S & FORTUNE INFRASTRUCTURE VS TREVOR DLIMA & ORS. efc-MRTlcT-M cfR if 3ff%cT TT t:- f^ 15. Moreover, a person cannot be made to wait indefinitely for the possession of the flats allotted to them and they are entitled to seek the refund of the amount paid by them, along with compensation. Although we are aware of the fact that when there was no delivery period stipulated in the agreement, a reasonable time has to be taken into consideration. In the facts and circumstances of this case, a time period of 3 years would have been reasonable for completion of the contract i.e. the possession was required to be given by last quarter of 2014. Further there is no dispute as to the fact that until now there is no redevelopment of the property. Hence, in view of the above discussion, which draw us to an irresistible conclusion that there is deficiency of service on the part of the appellants and accordingly the issue is answered, when once comes to the conclusion that, there is deficiency of services, then the question is what
compensation the respondents/ complainants is entitled to.
cf> 3fldl4> 2TI? Pi cep4 Plcpidi uTT 'deftcl I t f% fuH if PHPI Heft^if cjSf fcrRr TH? Ff r TFRcT eftt Ridel ^ci MRR^PI^ cf^ ^ eftf^ TcT TFRTTcfPr cp5T P|£|Ru| f$TcT PldPl 30 W 3 11 TjfcT fcPTSft eftaRTFJTTRftuT^ 3T^ ^ TT VJTFTT 2TT eft 3j1q -qiReftcll3Tf eft TiRT 36 W i if uTFf %cj Wkl 11 cfts^f^ iff^ f^ cf>T 3fmcH .2016 Rleft IdeleftCli TfT 'TRT if KJefcT eftf Rd left—27.01 eft ^-TST t^ yeftK cftsjii§cft|^ cfcfj8TTI vil'i'ScI .2019 TT WTT £fT| Rq|eft—27.01 36 *ffi? dlRk* fc^ ^Rmaft eftt Haddd qRqluidl Hvjilcftxjui 'd'dsqi— if Hullc£cl f fuRTepT
SR7S T-UPRERAPRJ4769 11 PPTSff SR] *fr£cT *R HR4luHI eft Pf ^ft fcrf^ ^04.01.2017 T fcpTaft eft ^cf tffMuRT xjxjfcTT 1cfRT-03.07.2019 3Tfcfjcf eft t, fuf^ 4 1' s /e >£ /u£fP PPj'h (£ p 'pfPb /Uf(?/tn /* P(J !t?c£J P£JJk(J /?#£/ J(h 8 M utblhSi, Ah <h IPU\(h>jh hSit hPJH> ££? Jn& £? cblcb cb^JPMb of* !P(bP> //n /g bh b£Uf\£j h£/P Jch [Pbb. Z
Ipifc/ulfa jm ^ -g 'lUja Pbk+kJ J£\ <bl?* bllfr lUIln lh>c^J OLOp\ kk lnXcb|UNh £ Kub+IN c£ UbjXhPv g> ^ JUIKi^JIh/pifc PfrJ|frkj ItbPjjfi IPcblN [Ml ibcjaj upb^ jh kh. U^ IUN&J h£io |^ |9b PPJkjtt J<k tathfctt? ktflih^ Jkkk <£}|U>g>JI^ JPN £ Z-NkNK 11 IMt 11?^ | Ml HI-N pikkj £ IHnlr Jtk Ifrfrjh Nhfc bk*l» Upb^Jh J± JNb MUMb jck ^ J^fe. |PtblN PfcjjfcUj klkpb (k PIJK+I-N kMt |JnM4> pia^Jhtfi J[± PkjlkfcK> I^ ifc j <k Utbifrok j pfrpj :\M£ \ 2M-2& J4|lM±i3 ^ ^p^ c^ ^ XIH&lft lh]^ kkk kj^ tbbJP-NIb Ml <k lUkvjb^Jh J<k ptbPblcbl^ j Ikk. Ibt^J PB>jlAO|c\ Jj IZOTOV VO ^j khlfr MB |fth|3j {± kl lkisl£ l3M*±& 'J£k <blk^ kis^kj^ Pt^JI^J k&k 4>k \£MlIMkfclkbkj i^ jiMMs PbfrjPJte |bk ipik IMS |tt?h|pj ibb t$y. ^ jixun l jgk Male|. Mk>tlikbuj i^ j. Ikk % IkbltA Ibcfl bkfckj ab £ £±j|J k£ UfefcJI^Jfe [frh. 4pik IMS jjah^ InMUNkj Z-lhSNUTt^|9j s^|9j MINfckP I £ |nIUN J$k PfcJIPMj L-lh5>l->
j Iklnk I IpfrIUN [$> P1QJMK> £ 6 V0Z‘ V0‘IZ cbiu^ IkUN b Pb P|PK ab J£ Pbfr k |k?h|3j £ IPIa Ig. i£Uki PbtjPI^J kil^ ^JP^J ^Jh ^ ^ :kie lch-lnlkK IMS lUUNjb 0202 Mt I lizk kk p>IUN IPp& J J 2^62 (ph^ ^Jh Ib^ ^k Neb cbP Us OZOZ' ZVOZ IMt <k Pkbo|!> p jlPNjpj joJlcb (j fiL-S- J J Ib^ ^ <blU^ cbkJ^ kbbllft 9-1MJ3 k 9103 'kbkjbJK- kil kkbkj(3j) Ml (l^lcbbj Ikhii^-lt 1M^^ ^
ft eilvIN ft ffisf WWfficF $ / 20 Ilf?}?/ cl ft 3jf$fo> cjffg eftft W 3tlJq<P Zfft mi? eft Wpft gft epfflffr fetm fffrtft <Pd1cf) ft faff &JEW ft wcr eft? warn #/ vJH'dcKi crf&fcT ?T?ff TJcf iqc?l vJHd«J STfftcRft ft *IF W ftcTT f % H^ fcrqafr irreT R-110 03.08.2021 -w% ft ^NTC^ CI ft 1jfft=rcfjT ft 20 yfcklci eft ^Tct ft SRTftft t cT^TT Hdl0^ul cT^^ ft vjft eft^t tffodRsm ?lft ft 3RWT XJcf RiqHI^'MK 11 K ffte?; ft^TT-2 PlwiRa eft uuft 11 CI^^ Pj'K1Kul ft<gj| —3 fft^ q fcfnjr dlftll F*T ffte£ Zf^ Pl^ fft w Ricniqacnai eft cjj®5TT cf fcTdReld ^ ^STcrfft efTT eZTM RdNI Wft ? ftft FT eft fftZT cR ft ?
feld^q ft ft vJoftoftlq t fft ^ZTFTTePT ft ftld >Hd ^T*«RT vJ^cf <* *16RI^ «MI*1 3TPT> qiftqu| eft ^jfftzpfR^dctft ^R3rftr JTT.fcT. SllR $R^iJ| ftt ZUfftcR ft 3Tft ft 2JT fft :- ^TF efft feRTT ^FTT
Section 4(2)(l)(c) enables the promoter to revise the date of completion of project and hand over possession. The provisions of RERA, however, do not rewrite the clause of completion or handing over possession in agreement for sale. Section 4(2)(l)(c) enables the promoter to give fresh time line independent of the time period stipulated in the agreements for sale entered into between him and the allottees so that he is not visited with penal consequences laid down under RERA. In other words, by giving opportunity to the promoter to prescribe fresh time line under Section 4(2)(l)(c) he is not absolved of liability under the agreement for sale. Section 18(l)(b) lays down that if the promoter fails to complete or is unable to give possession of an apartment due to discontinuance of his business as a developer on account of suspension
6 * or revocation of the registration under the Act or for any other reason, he is liable on demand to the allottees, in case the allottee wishes to withdraw from the project, without prejudice in this behalf including compensation. If the allottee does not intent to withdraw from the project he shall be paid by the promoter interest for every month's delay till handing over of the possession. The requirement to pay interest is not a penalty as the payment of interest is compensatory in nature in the light of the delay suffered by the allottee who has paid for his apartment but has not received possession of it. The obligation imposed on the promoter to pay interest till such time as the apartment is handed over to him is not unreasonable. The interest is merely compensation for use of money.
’ cf> SndW 3 t 1% \303T0 cfc HlRbMM'l cf> 3TcT: vm'lxp Rr°fa ^ +l'loi cT ?JKTT cf> T STJSRT cf> Rld**l cTSJT TJdar^fcT iil Rb^^ epRTf^ «2jTv5T SRII, <r4iRb SKI VJH -HIJI Rb^-ii ^Tci) TRTT f i 3 RiRid dsi cTcfj Rb'M cfrr SZTM Rdi*) VJTT^^ t^ vETccJcFT 0 6649—50/ 2018 IdRlci'S «MlH pul’ll3H51d ^ ^ TRT t Rfr-^TRTeRT IfNT SfRlPtalRcl Rb^lT
“The period of Interest should close on April 2016 when the Full Occupancy Certificate was obtained as per the admission of the Respondent- Purchaser herself in Para 4(j) of the Consumer Complaint, wherein she has admitted that the Appellant-Builder had obtained the Completion Certificate as late as April 2016. The Respondent - Purchaser could not have any further grievance after April 2016 with respect to delay in handing over possession. The Respondent-Purchaser ought not to be allowed to reap the benefits of her own delay in taking possession”. CJXI "idk R wr qRIci t Rb IVJHI 3 R)d +<t cj5t SfcfRr VJH^ ^ MR^ ^ PTRT clef) ajSjcfT 0MI 3TFM Rf)JIUMI, MR4)VJHI 3fto^to/^to#0 Rb^ dl^l 2/ 7 cfcfj cf>T RelHRRr ufr ft 00 3 ft Ft0T I 3lf$|0|^ 0^
RHIch-27.01.2016 0T 11 36 W vjfteet Fd JRj'fur HIJN^I 3 STTcf^T ^r/ cpcull 0T Rni0-27.O1.2O19 cTcf> R^TT VJTPTT niRkj SIT| fcfaaft gRT ^FcfRcT HR^ IVJI^ Rm'0 29.12.2020 0t 00T R>0 uTT 30 cTSTT Rqafr gRT TJ0T3lt0^0/^t0#0 Rl0|i|c10dl 0t '(Rl'lRfcT N '0?T Rni0 03.08.2021 0t ORd Rxn 00 0| 30: H^ TcTWS SreRUT i\ RdRcid 3TclR R 0M eft J|uMI Rni0 27.01.2019 ^T^ftf^ vjfPTT | 00 F)ft cR RRl 03.08.2021 00 R>0 ^itflRid ITcftcT FidT f5-R?M VJII^ 00 VJOSTO SRnRcTl gRT Rni0 00 'tin >td 'ij'tind d&ft R
MR4)vHI3?f20.05.2020 0t 0lR <s-19 (Corona Virus Disease) R 000 R 0R0 0^0t Tjpt RdT0 25.03.2020 6 W 4 3T8lfcT RdT0 25.09.2020 d0 ^ gSt STcfR ft^ nft t? 3fft 0F sifter 0WI ftsft? 3jft£r ni*Tl viiRft| ^ ^^0) <jR^id wt R00 25.03.2020 ft R0T0 25.09.2020 00 gRft^Hi 3^ Rrew RT fttl? &MM ftftcR gRT 3j|c|Rft SfciR chT 3Jl0eM n£l Rbm viiRni 030 ^0t 0# Rm 3fft 0 Ri0i <id0dl ft ^Rel*N «2TP3T feRTT ni I 0t^ ull^ lK 'd'isqi—3 Pl*dlRd d^ uTTcft 11 3TR?T
gft ftifft 1. fftrft ftt aiRRm RRTT 0TT0T t ft? 0? STR?T HVCI 0? Snell'S Fft ft 60 ftd ft 3R0? 00T 0? R0n—ReH Rl0Nd0di 0t 0T 0®J1 I MnM PiRdd 0$ I 0^10^ 0^m ^ §01^ 2. ftgft, Rl0Nd0dI 0t RelRcid 3lftft ft feT0 Rni0 Rni0 27.01.2019 ft 'tRilRd ?H— '00 wft f cR frfRr 03.08.2021 cR ^0 sfgRr R feR y^ 0^ ^ t0 3JJ0 Ff^dT gRT RfelfRd MCLR+1% ^ RclfRd &00 3IFT W ^ ^ PlRdd 0^ 1 «IIVJI g5t dF SPRIRT 3iPdn n,ndin Rd EFRTRT 0 EFRTRT f0 F"R 0? 'MHINLRID vnR ^fl 1 «IM EFRTRT ^ sif^ ^ H I 0Rf R[0T0d0df 0t 000 cj^t VJII^ ^00R 0t ^ Rcnd 0&cf 8 *x< R'llcp-25.03.2020 R'llR>—25.09.2020 HR-RVIMI Rel^l 62JM eft '•IuMl eft I ^^ vdl^l^fl
3. fcfaaft cf5t PRRm R^TT ^ VTTTCTT t k STRRRTH, 2016 Rt ETRT 2(za)(i) sqM efc i|R ?fR R sfK Rtf 3T5^TR ell^ ^ 3TTR£t R ^ eZJM UlRcK gRT Reftc-C RR UTR RRcK SKI fePTT uTTcTT t, eft vJ'ft ^ ^ R 3TTcRt Rt Rm UTTRTT ^RT I 3RT: RerfRcT ^ JldM RlcbNdcbdf R MCLR+I% Rt ^ R RT RTT 1 ?TR ^TTR arte R Rtf epRTRr RT eTPJ^ Rft t, eft RelRa 3TRR fcj &mviT fR R 6TK STTRft R Rel^ fsj eft Rt ETRTRT R vrR R JIUMI Rt viiiRfl 1 ^
TICR FT 3TTRT CR VSTTCTT t, eft Ricbiiici<+>rif Rt ^ft R^rr 4. RR Rrsft urn^ - ST^ yui R R 3FR 3TR?T CR ^n? 3TRC5R Rn Rj RT MiRc^ HI^H RJ-MM^H cf^r 1 ^iRR 3TR?T cf)T vicclfcM (RfRFR TR R >m) STRRR, 2016 Rt ^HHqi <* 3FTcfM fFTcT MlRoll'll R SFePfcT ^^fR fRlI 3TR?T Hlcfd ^&TRT—63 ?T2TT 3T^T ^Rrm VJTR I
//1/ 2021 / I %% 2' ^-l (^luflcl cj7*iK) smsf v?0TT0 RP|iJH0 L,l Mlft|0'/ 9