1 TATATATA No.98No.98No.98No.98 ofofofof 20220220220226262626 ININININ THETHETHETHE HIGHHIGHHIGHHIGH COURTCOURTCOURTCOURT OFOFOFOF PUNJAPUNJAPUNJAPUNJAABABABAB ANDANDANDAND HARYANAHARYANAHARYANAHARYANA ATATATAT CHANDIGACHANDIGACHANDIGACHANDIGAARHARHARHARH 110+213 CMCMCMCM No.13365-CNo.13365No.13365No.13365 CIICIICIICII ofofofof 2026202620262026 in/andin/andin/andin/and Transferransferransferransfer ApplicApplicApplicAppliccationcationationation No.98No.No.No.989898 ofofofof 2026202620262026 (O&M)(O&M)(O&M)(O&M) DateDateDateDate ofofofof DecisionDecisionDecisionDecisionn:n:n:n: 13.07.2026131313.07.2026.07.2026.07.2026 AMANPREETAMANPREETAMANPREETAMANPREET KKAURKKAURKAURKAUR .................... .ApplicantApplicantApplicantApplicant VsVsVsVs ASHVINDERASHVINDERASHVINDERASHVINDER KKAURKKAURKKAURKKAUR ANDANDANDAND ORS.ORS.ORS.ORS. …..Respondent(s)…..Respondent(s)……..Respondent(s)…..Respondent(s) CORAM:CORAM:CORAM:CORAM: HONHONHONHONN'BLEN'BLEN'BLEN'BLEMR.MR.MR.MR.JUSTICEJUSTICEJUSTICEJUSTICEHARKESHHARKESHHARKESHHARKESHHHHHMANUJAMANUJAMANUJAMANUJA Present: Mr . Arnav Sood, Advocate for the applicant. Mr . Sandeep Gorsi, Advocate for respondent Nos.1 and 2. **** HARKESHHARKESHHARKESHHARKESHMAMAMAMAANUJA,ANUJA,ANUJA,ANUJA,J.J.J.J.(Oral)(Oral)(Oral)(Oral) CMCMCMCM No.No.No.No. 13365-133651336513365 CIICIICIICII ofofofof 2026202620262026 Forr the reasons mentioned in the application, the same is allowwed.

Written statemennt filed on behalf of respondent nnos.1 and 2 is taken on record. MainMainMainMain casecasecasecase 1.1.1.1. Thee applicant, by way of present application, seeks transfer of casec bearing No.CS/2No.CS/2No.CS/2No.CS/22246/2025,2246/2022246/2022246/202 titled “AshvinderAshvinderAshvinderAshvinder KaKaKaurKaurKaKaKaurKaur &&&& anotheranotheranotheranother vs.vs.vs.vs. AmanpreetAmanpreetAmanpreetAmanpreet KaurKaurKKKaurKaurKK andandandand others”,othersothersothers fileed at the instance of respondennt Nos.1 and 2; from the Courtt of learned Civil Juudge, Senior Division, Amritsar to the learned Court of compettent jurisdiction at DDasuya, District Hoshiarpur. 2.2.2.2. Briiefly stating, the marriage be tween the applicant and son of respondent Nos..1 and 2 was solemnized on 02.006.2024. On account of matrimonnial discord betweenn the applicant and her husband, she moved a complaint and lodgged MOHMED ATIK 2026.07.16 09:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 2 TATATATA No.98No.98No.98No.98 ofofofof 20220220220226262626 FIR against her husband and respondent Nos.1 & 2, which are pending at Dasuuya, District Hoshiarrpur. It has been alleged that inn order to harass the applicant, the abovementionedd civil suit came to be preferred at the instance of respondent Noos.1 and 2. Thereupoon, the present application seekinng transfer thereof came to be fiiled by the applicant .

3. Leaarned counsel for the applicaant, inter alia, contends that the applicant is resiiding with her parents and oldd grand-parents at Dasuya, Disttrict Hoshiarpur. Acccordingly, a prayer is made fo r transfer of the above mentionned civil suit filed att the instance of respondent Noss.1 and 2, from the Court of learnned Civil Judge, SSenior Division, Amritsar to the learned Court of compettent jurisdiction at DDasuya, District Hoshiarpur. 4. On the other hand, learned counnsel for respondent Nos.1 andd 2 vehemently opp oses the prayer made on behalf oof the applicant. 5. I hhave heard learned counsel for the parties and gone through the paper-book. 6. In tthe present case, admittedly, th e applicant has filed the followwing cases which are pending adjudication before th e learned Court at Dasuya, Disttrict Hoshiarpur:- (1) Complaint bearing FIR No.885 dated 28.09.2025 under Secttion 85 of BNS registered at P.S. Daasuya, District Hoshiarpur agaiinst resppondent No.2 and his son. (2) Complaint under Sections 112, 18, 19, 20, 22 and 23 of the Prootection of Women from Domesttic Violence Act, 2005. MOHMED ATIK 2026.07.16 09:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 3 TATATATA No.98No.98No.98No.98 ofofofof 20220220220226262626 (3) Petition under Section 144 BBNS (Earlier Section 125 Cr.P..C.) for grant of maintenance allowancee.

7. As per the averments made in thhe present transfer application, the applicant-wife iis residing with her parents annd has no independent source of income. The appplicant is facing great difficulty iin bearing the litigation charges anda travelling expennses in pursuing the and for the financials, she is totally dependdent upon her parentss.

8.8.8.8. Thee parameters governing exercisee of jurisdiction of Section 24 of the CPC, are not loonger res integra. In N.C.V.N.C.V.N.C.V.N.C.V. AisAisAisAisshwaryashwaryashwaryashwarya vs.vs.vs.vs. A.S.A.S.A.S.A.S. SaravanaSaravanaSaravanaSaravana KartKartKartKartthikthikthikthik Sha,Sha,Sha,Sha,2022(7)2022(7)2022(7)2022(7)SCSCSCSCCCCCCCCC328,328,328,328,the Hon’ble Supreme C ourt held that the cardinal princiiple while exercisingg power under Section 24 CPCC is that the ends of justice mustm warrant the traansfer. The Hon’ble Court, furrther held that, while considerring transfer in matrrimonial matters, the Courts haave to take into consideration the economic sounddness of both the parties, the soocial strata of the spouses and thheir behavioural pat tern, their standard of life prioor to the marriage and subsequuent thereto and the circumstances of both the partiees in eking out their livelihood anda under whose prrotective umbrella they are seeeking their sustenance to life. TheT Hon’ble Court aalso emphasized that where multtiple proceedings between the soome parties are pendding before different Courts innvolving common questions, itt is desirable that thhey should be tried together b y the same Court, so as to avvoid multiplicity of pproceedings and conflicting decissions.

9. Appplying the aforesaid principles tto the facts of the present case, thist Court finds thatt the applicant-wife is residing wwith her parents at Dasuya, has no independent soource of income; already proosecuting proceedings under the MOHMED ATIK 2026.07.16 09:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 4 TATATATA No.98No.98No.98No.98 ofofofof 20220220220226262626 Protection of WWomen from D.V. Act, the mmaintenance proceedings and the criminal case at Dasuya. Requiring her to conteest the present civil suit at Amrittsar would result inn unnecessary hardship, finanncial burden and multiplicity of proceedings. Onn the contrary, transfer of the ccivil suit at Dasuya would neitther prejudice the reespondents or cause them any iirreparable inconvenience, while it would facilitate effective adjudication of all d isputes between the parties at oneo place and obviatte the possibility of conflicting fifindings.

10. Connsidering the aforesaid facts aand circumstances, in the hummble opinion of this Court, since three cases filed aat the instance of the applicant, are pending adjudiccation at Dasuya, District Hoshiiapur,,,, therefore, it would be in the interest of both the parties that all their cases b e heard together at the same plaace. Consequently tthe transfer application is alloalloalloalloowedowedowedowed and the civil suit bearring No.CS/2246/202CS/2246/202CS/2246/202CS/2246/20225, titled “AshvinderAshvinderAshvinderAshvinder KaurKaurKaurKaur &&&& anotheranotheranotheranother vs.vs.vs.vs. AmanpreetAmanpreetAmanpreetAmanpreet KaurKaurKaurKaur andandaaandandaa others”,othersothersothers filed byy respondent Nos.1 and 2, stannds transferred from the Courtt of learned Civil Juudge, Senior Division, Amritsar to the learned Court of compettent jurisdiction at DDasuya, District Hoshiarpur. Thhe requisite record of the aforessaid case be sent by tthe learned Trial Court to the Coourt concerned. 11. Pennding miscellaneous application((s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. (HA(HA(HA(HAARKESHARKESHARKESHARKESH MANUJA)MANUJA)MANUJA)MANUJA) JulyJulyJulyJuly 13,131313,,, 2026202020262626 JUDGEJUDGEJUDGEJUDGE Atik Whhether speaking/reasoned Yess/No Whhether reportable Yess/No MOHMED ATIK 2026.07.16 09:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment

1 TATATATA No.98No.98No.98No.98 ofofofof 20220220220226262626 ININININ THETHETHETHE HIGHHIGHHIGHHIGH COURTCOURTCOURTCOURT OFOFOFOF PUNJAPUNJAPUNJAPUNJAABABABAB ANDANDANDAND HARYANAHARYANAHARYANAHARYANA ATATATAT CHANDIGACHANDIGACHANDIGACHANDIGAARHARHARHARH 110+213 CMCMCMCM No.13365-CNo.13365No.13365No.13365 CIICIICIICII ofofofof 2026202620262026 in/andin/andin/andin/and Transferransferransferransfer ApplicApplicApplicAppliccationcationationation No.98No.No.No.989898 ofofofof 2026202620262026 (O&M)(O&M)(O&M)(O&M) DateDateDateDate ofofofof DecisionDecisionDecisionDecisionn:n:n:n: 13.07.2026131313.07.2026.07.2026.07.2026 AMANPREETAMANPREETAMANPREETAMANPREET KKAURKKAURKAURKAUR .................... .ApplicantApplicantApplicantApplicant VsVsVsVs ASHVINDERASHVINDERASHVINDERASHVINDER KKAURKKAURKKAURKKAUR ANDANDANDAND ORS.ORS.ORS.ORS. …..Respondent(s)…..Respondent(s)……..Respondent(s)…..Respondent(s) CORAM:CORAM:CORAM:CORAM: HONHONHONHONN'BLEN'BLEN'BLEN'BLEMR.MR.MR.MR.JUSTICEJUSTICEJUSTICEJUSTICEHARKESHHARKESHHARKESHHARKESHHHHHMANUJAMANUJAMANUJAMANUJA Present: Mr . Arnav Sood, Advocate for the applicant. Mr . Sandeep Gorsi, Advocate for respondent Nos.1 and 2. **** HARKESHHARKESHHARKESHHARKESHMAMAMAMAANUJA,ANUJA,ANUJA,ANUJA,J.J.J.J.(Oral)(Oral)(Oral)(Oral) CMCMCMCM No.No.No.No. 13365-133651336513365 CIICIICIICII ofofofof 2026202620262026 Forr the reasons mentioned in the application, the same is allowwed.

Written statemennt filed on behalf of respondent nnos.1 and 2 is taken on record. MainMainMainMain casecasecasecase 1.1.1.1. Thee applicant, by way of present application, seeks transfer of casec bearing No.CS/2No.CS/2No.CS/2No.CS/22246/2025,2246/2022246/2022246/202 titled “AshvinderAshvinderAshvinderAshvinder KaKaKaurKaurKaKaKaurKaur &&&& anotheranotheranotheranother vs.vs.vs.vs. AmanpreetAmanpreetAmanpreetAmanpreet KaurKaurKKKaurKaurKK andandandand others”,othersothersothers fileed at the instance of respondennt Nos.1 and 2; from the Courtt of learned Civil Juudge, Senior Division, Amritsar to the learned Court of compettent jurisdiction at DDasuya, District Hoshiarpur. 2.2.2.2. Briiefly stating, the marriage be tween the applicant and son of respondent Nos..1 and 2 was solemnized on 02.006.2024. On account of matrimonnial discord betweenn the applicant and her husband, she moved a complaint and lodgged MOHMED ATIK 2026.07.16 09:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 2 TATATATA No.98No.98No.98No.98 ofofofof 20220220220226262626 FIR against her husband and respondent Nos.1 & 2, which are pending at Dasuuya, District Hoshiarrpur. It has been alleged that inn order to harass the applicant, the abovementionedd civil suit came to be preferred at the instance of respondent Noos.1 and 2. Thereupoon, the present application seekinng transfer thereof came to be fiiled by the applicant .

3. Leaarned counsel for the applicaant, inter alia, contends that the applicant is resiiding with her parents and oldd grand-parents at Dasuya, Disttrict Hoshiarpur. Acccordingly, a prayer is made fo r transfer of the above mentionned civil suit filed att the instance of respondent Noss.1 and 2, from the Court of learnned Civil Judge, SSenior Division, Amritsar to the learned Court of compettent jurisdiction at DDasuya, District Hoshiarpur. 4. On the other hand, learned counnsel for respondent Nos.1 andd 2 vehemently opp oses the prayer made on behalf oof the applicant. 5. I hhave heard learned counsel for the parties and gone through the paper-book. 6. In tthe present case, admittedly, th e applicant has filed the followwing cases which are pending adjudication before th e learned Court at Dasuya, Disttrict Hoshiarpur:- (1) Complaint bearing FIR No.885 dated 28.09.2025 under Secttion 85 of BNS registered at P.S. Daasuya, District Hoshiarpur agaiinst resppondent No.2 and his son. (2) Complaint under Sections 112, 18, 19, 20, 22 and 23 of the Prootection of Women from Domesttic Violence Act, 2005. MOHMED ATIK 2026.07.16 09:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 3 TATATATA No.98No.98No.98No.98 ofofofof 20220220220226262626 (3) Petition under Section 144 BBNS (Earlier Section 125 Cr.P..C.) for grant of maintenance allowancee.

7. As per the averments made in thhe present transfer application, the applicant-wife iis residing with her parents annd has no independent source of income. The appplicant is facing great difficulty iin bearing the litigation charges anda travelling expennses in pursuing the and for the financials, she is totally dependdent upon her parentss.

8.8.8.8. Thee parameters governing exercisee of jurisdiction of Section 24 of the CPC, are not loonger res integra. In N.C.V.N.C.V.N.C.V.N.C.V. AisAisAisAisshwaryashwaryashwaryashwarya vs.vs.vs.vs. A.S.A.S.A.S.A.S. SaravanaSaravanaSaravanaSaravana KartKartKartKartthikthikthikthik Sha,Sha,Sha,Sha,2022(7)2022(7)2022(7)2022(7)SCSCSCSCCCCCCCCC328,328,328,328,the Hon’ble Supreme C ourt held that the cardinal princiiple while exercisingg power under Section 24 CPCC is that the ends of justice mustm warrant the traansfer. The Hon’ble Court, furrther held that, while considerring transfer in matrrimonial matters, the Courts haave to take into consideration the economic sounddness of both the parties, the soocial strata of the spouses and thheir behavioural pat tern, their standard of life prioor to the marriage and subsequuent thereto and the circumstances of both the partiees in eking out their livelihood anda under whose prrotective umbrella they are seeeking their sustenance to life. TheT Hon’ble Court aalso emphasized that where multtiple proceedings between the soome parties are pendding before different Courts innvolving common questions, itt is desirable that thhey should be tried together b y the same Court, so as to avvoid multiplicity of pproceedings and conflicting decissions.

9. Appplying the aforesaid principles tto the facts of the present case, thist Court finds thatt the applicant-wife is residing wwith her parents at Dasuya, has no independent soource of income; already proosecuting proceedings under the MOHMED ATIK 2026.07.16 09:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 4 TATATATA No.98No.98No.98No.98 ofofofof 20220220220226262626 Protection of WWomen from D.V. Act, the mmaintenance proceedings and the criminal case at Dasuya. Requiring her to conteest the present civil suit at Amrittsar would result inn unnecessary hardship, finanncial burden and multiplicity of proceedings. Onn the contrary, transfer of the ccivil suit at Dasuya would neitther prejudice the reespondents or cause them any iirreparable inconvenience, while it would facilitate effective adjudication of all d isputes between the parties at oneo place and obviatte the possibility of conflicting fifindings.

10. Connsidering the aforesaid facts aand circumstances, in the hummble opinion of this Court, since three cases filed aat the instance of the applicant, are pending adjudiccation at Dasuya, District Hoshiiapur,,,, therefore, it would be in the interest of both the parties that all their cases b e heard together at the same plaace. Consequently tthe transfer application is alloalloalloalloowedowedowedowed and the civil suit bearring No.CS/2246/202CS/2246/202CS/2246/202CS/2246/20225, titled “AshvinderAshvinderAshvinderAshvinder KaurKaurKaurKaur &&&& anotheranotheranotheranother vs.vs.vs.vs. AmanpreetAmanpreetAmanpreetAmanpreet KaurKaurKaurKaur andandaaandandaa others”,othersothersothers filed byy respondent Nos.1 and 2, stannds transferred from the Courtt of learned Civil Juudge, Senior Division, Amritsar to the learned Court of compettent jurisdiction at DDasuya, District Hoshiarpur. Thhe requisite record of the aforessaid case be sent by tthe learned Trial Court to the Coourt concerned. 11. Pennding miscellaneous application((s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. (HA(HA(HA(HAARKESHARKESHARKESHARKESH MANUJA)MANUJA)MANUJA)MANUJA) JulyJulyJulyJuly 13,131313,,, 2026202020262626 JUDGEJUDGEJUDGEJUDGE Atik Whhether speaking/reasoned Yess/No Whhether reportable Yess/No MOHMED ATIK 2026.07.16 09:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment